| 2' | ⚽ Jesus Manuel Corona Ruiz [0-1] |
| 🟨 John Brooks | 10' | |
| ⚽ Giovanni Reyna [1-1] | 27' | |
| 🟨 Kellyn Acosta | 49' | |
| 🔄 Timothy Tarpeh Weah (Sergino Gianni Dest) | 60' | |
| 66' | 🔄 Luis Francisco Romo Barron (Carlos Alberto Rodriguez Gomez) |
| 66' | 🔄 Henry Martin (Jesus Manuel Corona Ruiz) |
| 🔄 Theoson Jordan Siebatcheu (Joshua Sargent) | 68' | |
| 🔄 Ethan Horvath (Zackary Steffen) | 69' | |
| 78' | 🔄 Diego Lainez Leyva (Carlos Uriel Antuna Romero) |
| 79' | ⚽ Diego Lainez Leyva (Hirving Rodrigo Lozano Bahena) [1-2] |
| ⚽ Weston James Earl McKennie (Giovanni Reyna) [2-2] | 82' | |
| 🔄 Brenden Aaronson (Giovanni Reyna) | 83' | |
| 🔄 Sebastian Lletget (Timothy Michael Ream) | 83' | |
| 🟨 Mark McKenzie | 86' | |
| 90+2' | 🟨 Hector Miguel Herrera Lopez |
| 🟨 DeAndre Yedlin | 90+4' | |
| 100' | 🔄 Jose Andres Guardado Hernandez (Hector Miguel Herrera Lopez) |
| 100' | 🔄 Carlos Salcedo Hernandez (Hector Alfredo Moreno Herrera) |
| 🔄 Reginald Jacob Cannon (DeAndre Yedlin) | 105+1' | |
| 108' | 🟨 Hirving Rodrigo Lozano Bahena |
| 113' | 🟥 Martino G. |
| ⚽ (P) Christian Pulisic [3-2] | 114' | |
| 🟨 Christian Pulisic | 115' | |
| 116' | 🔄 Orbelin Pineda Alvarado (Edson Omar Alvarez Velazquez) |
| 120+1' | 🟨 Jose Andres Guardado Hernandez |
| 120+3' | ❌ (P) Jose Andres Guardado Hernandez |
